Re: BUG: using smp_processor_id() in preemptible [00000000] code: TCPTSK/1809


Rainer Kloud
 

I notice you are using -rt kernel. Do you actually need realtime
features?
Yes, I actually need the realtime feature. I have one task which
needs to run periodically in realtime (triggered every 10ms by an
external IRQ).
How fast response do you need to the external IRQ?
We do not have "Hard-Realtime" requirements, but we should always handle the IRQ inside of 1ms.

Can you try to reproduce the problem on 4.19.193?
This is only a problem with the realtime patch. The patch
introduces migrate_enable which is part of the callstack:

Jun 1 09:11:46 sicam kernel: [46802.944165] BUG: using smp_processor_id() in preemptible [00000000] code: TCPTSK/1809
Jun 1 09:11:46 sicam kernel: [46802.944210] caller is
migrate_enable+0x40/0x488
Fun :-(. As Jan mentioned, testing if it can be reproduced with
4.19.193-rt81 would be useful.
Ok, I will give 4.19.193-rt81 a try.

Before we decided to switch to the 4.19.x kernel we tried in March this year the 5.10.25 kernel with -rt35.
There we observed a very bad realtime behaviour. Our external interrupt had a latency of more then 4ms when our complete application was running. The IRQ task has realtime prio 51 and is therefore over all other IRQ tasks in the system (they have by default 50).
With kernel 4.19.x we do not see a latency over 1ms in the same configuration.

Best regards,
Rainer

Join cip-dev@lists.cip-project.org to automatically receive all group messages.